Rework platform billing: per-plan clocks, grace from period start

Implements BILLING.md. The architecture was sound -- snapshot-on-Due,
dated prices, asymmetric dry-run commands are all kept -- so this
fixes the three hardcoded assumptions rather than rewriting.

The real defect: grace ran from period_END, so an annual club used
the whole unpaid year plus 45 days (~410 days) before anything
switched it off. Grace now runs from the period START, and every
clock is per-plan.

- Tier -> Plan (+ TierPrice -> PlanPrice, and every FK). Migration
  0004 is hand-written: run non-interactively, makemigrations emits
  DeleteModel+CreateModel and drops every price, subscription and
  due. Its two RemoveConstraints must come first, or SQLite's
  table-rebuild tries to render a constraint over a just-renamed
  column. Verified by round-tripping real rows through it.
- Plan gains duration_months / renewal_lead_days / grace_days /
  is_trial, with CheckConstraints and a matching clean() so the form
  reports an impossible plan instead of 500ing on IntegrityError.
- Existing dues keep their stored grace_until. Re-deriving it would
  put the date in the past for every open annual period and archive
  the entire paying customer base on the next --commit run.
- Trials take their length from the trial plan's own duration_months;
  start_trial() loses its trial_months argument.
- New BillingNotice service drives a club-facing warning: every level
  on the dashboard, and on every management page once urgent.
- send_billing_reminders emails club admins, once per escalation
  level so a daily cron is not a daily email. SMTP settings are
  env-driven and provider-agnostic; the backend defaults to console.
- Paying does not auto-restore an archived club -- the control panel
  surfaces a Reactivate prompt instead, since a club can also be
  archived by hand.
This commit is contained in:
2026-08-08 18:49:52 +02:00
parent ae93406853
commit fc6488ce55
36 changed files with 1342 additions and 386 deletions

View File

@@ -8,7 +8,8 @@ and has never been documented there. Once this design is implemented, §4 (the m
into `ARCHITECTURE.md` and this file keeps the lifecycle and operational detail, the same split
`DEPLOYMENT.md` already has with the rest of the docs.
Status: **proposed, not implemented.** Nothing in §4§9 exists on disk yet.
Status: **implemented.** The four decisions left open in §10 have been taken and are recorded
there.
---
@@ -375,18 +376,31 @@ which is expected — but the annotations themselves need renaming, not just re-
- `post_trial_plan` stays on `Subscription`, not on `Plan` — the same trial can convert to different
paid plans for different clubs.
**Still open — worth deciding before implementation:**
**Resolved during implementation:**
1. **Does full payment auto-restore an archived club?** Today `reactivate()` is explicit. Automatic
restoration is friendlier ("they paid, let them back in") but requires knowing the club was
archived *for non-payment* rather than by hand — which means an `archived_reason` field. The
cheap version is to leave it explicit and surface a prominent "Reactivate" action on any archived
club whose dues are now settled. Recommend the cheap version.
2. **Banner placement.** `management/home.html` only, or persistent in `management/base.html`? Home
matches the request; base is harder to ignore in the final week.
3. **Email reminders.** Out of scope here — the request is for an in-app warning — but a
`send_billing_reminders` command is the obvious follow-up, and the `BillingNotice` service in §6
is deliberately shaped so it could feed one without rework.
4. **Online payment.** Entirely out of scope. Every payment is still recorded by hand by a platform
admin (`record_payment`). Worth knowing that the warning tells a club admin money is due while
giving them no way to pay it in-app.
1. **Full payment does NOT auto-restore an archived club.** `reactivate()` stays an explicit
platform-admin action — a club can also be archived by hand for reasons that have nothing to do
with money, and an automatic restore would silently reverse that the next time a stray payment
was recorded. Instead, `_club_billing_card.html` shows a prominent prompt on any archived club
whose dues are settled, so the deliberate act is one click away. No `archived_reason` field was
needed.
2. **The banner escalates.** `management/home.html` renders it at every level; `management/base.html`
repeats it on every *other* management page only once it reaches `error` (≤7 days, or overdue).
Shown from the moment anything is owed it would sit on every screen for weeks and train people to
ignore the one week that matters.
3. **Email reminders are in.** `send_billing_reminders` (dry-run by default, `--commit` to send)
plus provider-agnostic SMTP settings read from the environment. Reminders go **once per
escalation level**, tracked on `Due.last_reminder_level`, because the command is on a daily cron
and a club that owes money for a month must not get thirty identical emails.
4. **Online payment stays out of scope.** Every payment is still recorded by hand by a platform
admin (`record_payment`). The consequence is real and worth stating: the banner and the reminder
email both tell a club admin money is due while giving them no way to pay it in-app. They pay by
transfer; you record it.
### The email default that will catch you out
`EMAIL_BACKEND` defaults to the **console backend**, not SMTP. That is deliberate — Django's own
default tries localhost:25 and raises `ConnectionRefused` on a box with no MTA — but it means a
deployment that forgets `DJANGO_EMAIL_HOST` will watch `send_billing_reminders --commit` report
success while no club hears anything. Set the mail variables in `.env.production` (see
`.env.production.example`) before trusting the job.